Key insights
While the media and law enforcement remain preoccupied with fraud against health insurance providers, scammers are taking advantage of open enrollment windows to target consumers:
- Fraud against insurers is staggering. For example, the 2026 National Health Care Fraud Takedown charged 455 defendants over $6.5 billion in false and fraudulent healthcare claims.[1]
- Medicare and ACA beneficiaries most in danger. Scammers heavily target the Medicare and Affordable Care Act open enrollment windows, posing as insurance agents, government officials, or “healthcare navigators.”
- Fear and pressure rule the day. Common tactics[2] include unsolicited calls demanding immediate action, fake websites mimicking legitimate marketplaces, and phishing emails promising better rates or warning that your coverage is about to lapse.
- Repeating patterns. Common red flags include pressure to take immediate action, requests for payment via gift cards or wire transfers, demands for Medicare IDs or Social Security numbers, and unrealistic offers.
What our expert says
To avoid falling victim to health insurance scams, Tomas Sinicki, managing director at Coveron, recommends that you:
- Never share details with unsolicited callers. Professionals offering legitimate enrollment assistance will never cold-call you demanding personal information, and Medicare will never call you to sell anything.
- Verify the identity of insurance agents. You can look up official state licensing databases or contact the agency they claim to represent through official channels.
- Type out official addresses instead of clicking links. Malicious ads or links in phishing emails could take you to a fake website dressed up as the official one, letting criminals steal any personal information or payment details you enter.
- Monitor your finances and policies. During the enrollment season, keep an eye on your financial accounts, credit reports, and Explanation of Benefits for any signs of misuse.
Call our helpline at 1-866-777-5561
Got a call from someone claiming to be a Medicare agent or received an email offering eye-popping insurance rates? Talk to us — we’ll help you figure out what happened and what to do next. The Coveron helpline is free and for everyone.
Methodology and sources
This article draws on two sources: the press release of the U.S. Attorney's Office, Southern District of Florida, titled “National health care fraud takedown results in 455 defendants charged in connection with over $6.5 billion in alleged fraud,” published on the official justice.gov opens in a new tab website, and the article “Open enrollment scams: how to spot and avoid health insurance fraud,” published by the National Cybersecurity alliance.
What is Scam-o-Meter?
Scam-o-Meter is an ongoing Coveron series where we keep track of online fraud. In each installment, we look at different scam or fraud trends, break down how they work, and share practical tips on how to protect yourself. We also share the latest data from our own research, our partners, and industry specialists.
References
[1] Press release of the U.S. Attorney's Office, Southern District of Florida (2026, June 25). “National health care fraud takedown results in 455 defendants charged in connection with over $6.5 billion in alleged fraud.”
Get dark web alerts plus up to $100K in eligible online-fraud coverage.
30-day money-back guarantee